Brighton & Hove Albion produced one of their finest away performances in years to beat Manchester United 3-2 at Old Trafford and reach the next round of the Carabao Cup. Fabian Hürzeler’s side trailed 2-0 with an hour gone, then scored three times in a devastating spell to turn the tie on its head.
| Team | Score | Goalscorers |
|---|---|---|
| Manchester United | 2 | Lacey, Mount |
| Brighton & Hove Albion | 3 | Kostoulas, Gross, De Cuyper |
1. Executive Match Summary & Scoreboard: Manchester United 2-3 Brighton
Debutant Shea Lacey and returning midfielder Mason Mount had put the hosts firmly in control before the break. Brighton’s response came through Charalampos Kostoulas, Pascal Gross and Maxim De Cuyper, each finding the net as United’s grip on the game loosened by the minute.
Brighton’s Remarkable Old Trafford Record
The result extends a remarkable record for Brighton at Old Trafford. This is their fifth straight season winning there. The second time in 2026 alone that they have knocked United out of a cup competition. For United, the statistics are startling in the other direction. Since Sir Alex Ferguson retired, they had led 2-0 at Old Trafford on 145 occasions. Winning every single one, until this defeat.
The night also carried a personal edge for Brighton. Carlos Baleba. Sold to United for £65m in the summer, he watched from the stands rather than the pitch. Baleba is still working his way back from injury as his old club dumped his new one out of the competition.
Carrick Faces Fresh Scrutiny
Michael Carrick’s team is already dealing with reports that 15-year-old academy prospect JJ Gabriel has indicated he wants to leave the club. This follows last weekend’s derby defeat and now faces further scrutiny after a fourth straight loss in domestic cup competitions.
Full detail on the numbers behind the collapse can be found in the Independent match report, while the build-up to Wednesday’s tie is covered in our pre-match cup preview.
2. Detailed First Half Narrative: Lacey and Mount Put Hosts Control
Carrick made changes in goal, handing Karl Darlow his United debut with Senne Lammens rested for the cup tie. The team selection reflected a club under pressure after a difficult week. United had already lost the Manchester Derby. The Gabriel story had added to a tense build-up around Old Trafford. None of that appeared to affect United’s start.
Old Trafford came alive early when Lacey, given his first start for the club, finished smartly to open the scoring. It made him the first United academy product to score on a maiden start since Marcus Rashford. This landmark lifted the home crowd and settled early nerves among Carrick’s changed side.
Brighton Struggle to Find a Rhythm
Brighton struggled in the opening exchanges. Hürzeler had spoken before the match about the challenges his side would face on this ground, a point covered in his pre-match comments. His players were second to every loose ball as United pressed with real intent through the middle third.
The second goal followed before half-time. Mason Mount, handed his first start of the season, arrived at the back post to double the lead and send United in at the interval fully in control.
Two goals up against a talented Brighton side, with the visitors offering little going forward. United looked set for a routine passage into the next round. Anyone checking the fixture details beforehand would have expected a comfortable home win given United’s momentum and Brighton’s slow start.
Brighton’s players trooped off at the break needing a response. Hürzeler had decisions to make, and the away end had gone quiet. Few inside Old Trafford could have predicted what was about to follow.
3. Detailed Second Half Narrative & Drama: Kostoulas, Gross and De Cuyper Complete Turnaround
Whatever Hürzeler said at half-time worked instantly. Brighton emerged with far more purpose, pushing higher up the pitch and forcing United’s back line into uncomfortable positions inside the opening minutes of the second period.
Kostoulas Sparks Brighton’s Comeback
Charalampos Kostoulas gave the visitors hope with a well-taken finish that halved the deficit and changed the tone of the contest completely. Old Trafford, so buoyant an hour earlier, grew nervous as Brighton began to dominate the ball and dictate the pace of the game.
Pascal Gross, Brighton’s most experienced head on the pitch, drew the sides level soon after. His equaliser stunned the home support and put United on the back foot for the first time all night. Carrick’s players, so composed in the opening half, began to look shaken as their two-goal cushion evaporated in front of their own supporters.
De Cuyper Completes the Turnaround
Brighton sensed the opportunity and kept pushing forward in numbers. Maxim De Cuyper completed the turnaround with the winning goal. This sparked scenes of celebration among the away supporters who had watched their side dominate the first hour from the wrong end of the scoreline. Darlow, left exposed by a defence that had lost its shape, could do little about any of the three goals conceded.
Brighton End United’s Long-Standing Record
The scale of the collapse cannot be overstated. United had never lost from 2-0 up at Old Trafford since Ferguson left the club. A run stretching back through 145 matches under a series of different managers. Brighton ended that run in the most dramatic circumstances, adding another chapter to their recent dominance on this ground.
For Carrick, the defeat means four straight losses in domestic cup competitions. This is an alarming sequence for a manager already under scrutiny following the derby result. Not to mention the unrest around Gabriel’s stated wish to leave.
Baleba, watching from the stands, saw his current club dumped out by the side that sold him. This is a stark reminder of the pedigree Brighton retain even after major departures from the squad.
4. Player Ratings: Manchester United
Karl Darlow (GK) – 5/10: Handed a surprise debut with Lammens rested, Darlow could not have asked for a tougher evening. He was well protected for an hour but had no realistic chance with any of Brighton’s three goals as his defence in front of him fell apart.
Manchester United’s back four – 5/10: Composed and disciplined while protecting a two-goal lead. The defensive unit lost its shape completely after the break. Brighton’s front players found space in behind repeatedly, and the collective collapse defined the closing stages of the tie.
Manchester United’s midfield – 5.5/10: Controlled possession well before the interval and helped build the platform for the opening two goals. Once Brighton raised their intensity after half-time, the midfield was overrun and offered little protection to an increasingly exposed back line.
Shea Lacey – 7/10: A debut start to remember for the academy graduate, who became the first United youth product to score on his first start since Marcus Rashford. Lacey’s early finish gave the hosts an ideal beginning, even if the result ultimately went against his side.
Mason Mount – 6.5/10: Making his first start of the season. Mount rewarded Carrick’s faith with a well-taken second goal that appeared to settle the tie before half-time. His influence faded after the break as Brighton took control of midfield and dictated the closing stages.
Manchester United’s forward line – 5/10: Sharp and direct in the first half, stretching Brighton’s defence and creating the space that led to both goals. The same threat never resurfaced after the interval as the team dropped deeper under sustained pressure from the visitors.
Substitutes – 5/10: Carrick’s changes from the bench failed to arrest Brighton’s momentum in the closing stages. Fresh legs could not restore the control United had enjoyed in the first half, and the introductions did little to prevent the eventual collapse.
5. Player Ratings: Brighton & Hove Albion
Brighton’s goalkeeper and back line – 6/10: Shaky in the opening half hour as United built a two-goal cushion, the defence settled after half-time and gave nothing else away. Early errors deep contributed to United’s dominance, but the unit steadied impressively once Hürzeler’s adjustments took effect.
Brighton’s midfield – 7/10: Anonymous for the first 45 minutes, the midfield transformed the game after the break by winning the ball higher up the pitch and feeding runners in behind. Their control of tempo in the second half was central to the comeback.
Charalampos Kostoulas – 7.5/10: The forward’s finish just after half-time changed the entire complexion of the tie, giving Brighton belief when they had offered little going forward beforehand. His movement and composure in front of goal proved decisive at a crucial moment in the contest.
Pascal Gross – 8/10: The experienced midfielder showed why he remains so trusted by Hürzeler. He drew the sides level with a composed equaliser that stunned Old Trafford. His calm influence helped steady Brighton during a difficult opening period before he inspired the fightback that followed.
Maxim De Cuyper – 8.5/10: The left-back capped a superb turnaround with the winning goal, completing one of Brighton’s great away performances in recent seasons. His attacking contribution throughout the second half epitomised the visitors’ relentless surge once United’s control began to slip.
Brighton’s forward line – 7/10: Ineffective before the break, the front players grew into the game as United tired and dropped deeper. Their movement created the space Kostoulas exploited for the first goal, setting the tone for a memorable second-half turnaround.
Substitutes – 7/10: Hürzeler’s changes from the bench added fresh energy at a pivotal stage, helping Brighton sustain their pressure as United visibly faded. The introductions played their part in a memorable night for the travelling supporters at Old Trafford.
This Brighton F.C. breaking news feature has been enhanced and enriched with confirmed live data with the support of generative AI and our data partners SportMonks.com. This helps us bring data-led news and information to you and other Brighton F.C. fans more efficiently and accurately, ensuring https://readbrighton.com is Brighton F.C. fans’ number 1 choice for independently published news. For more information you can view our editorial policy in our footer or email the team on [email protected].
